The knowledge and questions provided here will give you a clear, no‑spin review of the annuity you were shown. Index annuities can be useful, but they’re often marketed with selective information. This page focuses on what the product really does, what it doesn’t do, and the questions to ask to really know whether it fits your goals.

​

 

What You Were Likely Told

Reps usually highlight:

• “Market‑linked growth with no downside.”
• “You can earn up to X%.”
• “Guaranteed income for life if you follow the rules.”
• “Better than CDs. over longer periods of time”


These are technically true — but incomplete.



What You Weren’t Told

• You don’t get the index return. Only a limited portion based on a formula.
• Caps/participation rates can drop annually at the company's discretion.
• Income value isn’t real money. Only for calculating payouts.
• Liquidity is restricted. Usually, 10% per year for the first 5-10 years.
• Riders cost extra. Often 0.95%–1.25%. And they come off your account value.
• You might be better off with a simpler Multi Year Guaranteed Annuity where your results are 100% predictable

​​

 

​
Tough Questions to Ask the Salesperson

These expose the truth quickly.

Core Questions

1. What are the current caps/participation rates, and can they change?
2. What has this product actually credited over the last 10 years?
3. What are the surrender charges and how long do they last?
4. What is the rider fee and how is it deducted?
5. What is my real cash value vs. the income value?
6. What happens if I need more than 10% in a year?
7. What happens if I never use the income rider?
8. How are you compensated?


Hard‑Hitting Additional Questions to Ask

1. What are the insurer’s AM Best, S&P, Moody’s, and Fitch ratings — and any downgrades in the last five years?
2. Are these illustration numbers actual credited history or back tested hypotheticals?
3. Are any strategies excess‑return indexes, and what’s the fee drag or volatility target?
4. What is the company’s renewal‑rate history — do they cut caps after year one?
5. How much of the general account is BBB‑rated or below, and how much is in commercial real estate?
6. What is the real‑world average annual return for this exact product?
7. What is the maximum I could realistically earn in a strong market year based on today’s caps?
8. If I never turn on the income rider, what happens to the rider fees I paid?


If they dodge, deflect, or minimize, that’s your answer.



Final Assessment

A good annuity recommendation should feel transparent, logical, and aligned with your goals. If anything feels rushed or too good to be true, slow down. Like we mentioned earlier, you only get one chance to buy this product without penalty. Let our 44-years of experience with annuities help you.